A Sudden Change of Heart
In a move that’s sending shockwaves through both military and civil communities, U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has ordered the renaming of the USNS Harvey Milk, a fleet replenishment oiler named after the slain gay rights activist and Navy veteran. This decision aligns with the Trump administration’s broader initiative to eliminate references to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) within the military, emphasizing a return to a “warrior culture.”
The timing of this announcement, coinciding with LGBTQ+ Pride Month, has been met with significant criticism. Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi condemned the move as a “shameful, vindictive erasure” of civil rights figures’ legacies.
Who Was Harvey Milk?
Like him or not, Harvey Milk wasn’t your typical American politician—he was a groundbreaker, a fighter, and a man who lived on his own terms long before the system was ready for someone like him. Born in 1930, Milk would go on to become the first openly gay man elected to public office in California, winning a seat on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1977. But long before the spotlight of City Hall found him, he was a small business owner running a camera shop in San Francisco’s Castro District.
That shop didn’t just sell film and lenses—it became a headquarters for grassroots activism in a neighborhood quickly emerging as a safe haven for the gay community. Milk had a knack for rallying people, and he used that skill to help transform local politics into something that looked a little more like the people it was supposed to represent.
What a lot of people don’t know is that before Harvey Milk ever spoke into a bullhorn, he wore Navy blues. He enlisted in 1951, served during the Korean War, and became a diving instructor. He climbed the ranks to lieutenant junior grade before resigning his commission in early 1955 and accepting an “other than honorable” discharge once the service discovered his sexual preference.
But back then, being openly gay in the military wasn’t an option—it was typically a one-way ticket to a dishonorable discharge and potentially ruining any future job opportunities you may have. Officially, Milk only came out years later when he made the decision to run for office.
It says something about how far we’ve come that the U.S. Navy named a ship in his honor, recognizing both his service to the country and his fight for equal rights. It also says something about where we are now that they’re trying to erase his name from that ship.
Milk didn’t have much time in office, but he made it count. One of his key achievements was helping to pass a city ordinance that banned discrimination based on sexual orientation in housing, employment, and public services—a move that would ripple across the country in the decades that followed. But less than a year after taking office, Milk and San Francisco Mayor George Moscone were gunned down in City Hall by a disgruntled former supervisor.
A Sudden Change of Heart
In a move that’s sending shockwaves through both military and civil communities, U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has ordered the renaming of the USNS Harvey Milk, a fleet replenishment oiler named after the slain gay rights activist and Navy veteran. This decision aligns with the Trump administration’s broader initiative to eliminate references to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) within the military, emphasizing a return to a “warrior culture.”
The timing of this announcement, coinciding with LGBTQ+ Pride Month, has been met with significant criticism. Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi condemned the move as a “shameful, vindictive erasure” of civil rights figures’ legacies.
Who Was Harvey Milk?
Like him or not, Harvey Milk wasn’t your typical American politician—he was a groundbreaker, a fighter, and a man who lived on his own terms long before the system was ready for someone like him. Born in 1930, Milk would go on to become the first openly gay man elected to public office in California, winning a seat on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1977. But long before the spotlight of City Hall found him, he was a small business owner running a camera shop in San Francisco’s Castro District.
That shop didn’t just sell film and lenses—it became a headquarters for grassroots activism in a neighborhood quickly emerging as a safe haven for the gay community. Milk had a knack for rallying people, and he used that skill to help transform local politics into something that looked a little more like the people it was supposed to represent.
What a lot of people don’t know is that before Harvey Milk ever spoke into a bullhorn, he wore Navy blues. He enlisted in 1951, served during the Korean War, and became a diving instructor. He climbed the ranks to lieutenant junior grade before resigning his commission in early 1955 and accepting an “other than honorable” discharge once the service discovered his sexual preference.
But back then, being openly gay in the military wasn’t an option—it was typically a one-way ticket to a dishonorable discharge and potentially ruining any future job opportunities you may have. Officially, Milk only came out years later when he made the decision to run for office.
It says something about how far we’ve come that the U.S. Navy named a ship in his honor, recognizing both his service to the country and his fight for equal rights. It also says something about where we are now that they’re trying to erase his name from that ship.
Milk didn’t have much time in office, but he made it count. One of his key achievements was helping to pass a city ordinance that banned discrimination based on sexual orientation in housing, employment, and public services—a move that would ripple across the country in the decades that followed. But less than a year after taking office, Milk and San Francisco Mayor George Moscone were gunned down in City Hall by a disgruntled former supervisor.
It was a brutal end to a promising political career, but in death, Milk became even more powerful than he was in life. His legacy has inspired generations of activists, and his name remains synonymous with courage, authenticity, and the ongoing battle for recognition.
Harvey Milk was more than a symbol—he was a real person who risked (and ultimately gave) everything to speak up for those who couldn’t. And in that sense, he fits right in with the long line of Americans who changed history by refusing to be quiet.
The Ship’s Legacy
The USNS Harvey Milk (T-AO-206) is the second of the John Lewis-class of underway replenishment oilers, operated by the Military Sealift Command to support U.S. Navy ships . Named in 2016 by then-Secretary of the Navy Ray Mabus, the ship was part of an initiative to honor civil rights leaders, including John Lewis, Thurgood Marshall, and Cesar Chavez.
The ship was christened in 2021 and has since played a crucial role in refueling and resupplying Navy vessels at sea. Its naming was seen as a significant step toward inclusivity within the military, acknowledging the contributions of LGBTQ+ individuals to national service.
Political and Cultural Implications
The decision to rename the USNS Harvey Milk is kicking up a firestorm, and not just in military circles. With the announcement coming right as Pride Month kicks off, it’s hard not to see it as a political haymaker aimed at the LGBTQ+ community. To many, it feels like more than just a name change—it feels like an attempt to erase a piece of hard-earned history. Harvey Milk wasn’t some fringe figure. He served, and renaming a ship that was meant to honor both his service and his legacy sends a loud message, and for a lot of folks, that message isn’t a good one.
Culturally, to some in our nation, this move hits like a gut punch. Advocates and community leaders are calling it symbolic erasure, arguing that it undermines decades of progress made by the LGBTQ+ movement. To some it doesn’t matter one way or another and there is yet another group that thinks this is a move in the right direction. It says a lot about American society today.
The impact on military culture is no small thing either. Critics say this is part of a calculated retreat from efforts to create a military that reflects the diversity of the nation it defends. They’re worried it signals the beginning of a broader push to sideline anyone who doesn’t fit a narrow, outdated mold of what a “warrior” looks like. Veterans and LGBTQ+ organizations aren’t taking this lightly. Many are calling it a slap in the face—not just to Milk, but to every LGBTQ+ person who’s ever served in uniform, and estimates put that number close to one million. These are folks who wore the uniform, followed orders, and did their duty, only to see the government later turn its back on their contributions.
Politically, it’s clear what’s going on. The current administration has been pretty open about wanting to “reestablish the warrior culture” and roll back diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs across the military. They’re making no bones about the fact that this renaming is part of that agenda. It’s a play to reshape the image of the armed forces—more grit, less progressivism. But critics say it’s also rewriting history, choosing which stories get told and which get pushed aside.
And it’s not just the Harvey Milk that’s in the crosshairs. Other Navy ships named after civil rights leaders—like Harriet Tubman, Medgar Evers, and Ruth Bader Ginsburg—are also reportedly under review. That’s raised even more eyebrows, with opponents warning that this could become a systematic purging of figures who represent social change and equality. California lawmakers, including those who worked hard to get the ship named after Milk in the first place, are already slamming the decision. They’re calling it a divisive political stunt that risks alienating not just the LGBTQ+ community, but every American who believes in honoring those who fought for justice and equality.
In the end, this isn’t just about a name painted on the side of a ship. It’s about the soul of the country—what we value, who we remember, and the kind of legacy we want to leave behind.
A Reflection on Identity and Service
The renaming of the USNS Harvey Milk raises serious questions about how a nation honors its heroes and the values it chooses to uphold. Milk’s life and service exemplify courage and a commitment to equality, making the decision to remove his name from a naval vessel particularly poignant. And yes, I fully realize that there are multiple allegations of wrongdoing against Milk. Honestly, when you look at any high-ranking political or even military official who hasn’t had some mud tossed at them? But that isn’t what this renaming is about.
As the military navigates its identity in the 21st century, balancing tradition with acceptance of views outside the mainstream remains a complex challenge. The discourse surrounding the USNS Harvey Milk serves as a microcosm of the broader national conversation about representation, honor, and the evolving narrative of American history.
COMMENTS
There are
You must become a subscriber or login to view or post comments on this article.